Ahhhhhhhh I'm so sick of A.I. ahhhhhhhh!!!!!!!
When I first got access to Facebook more than 20 years (!!) ago, I was ecstatic. I had seen my friends at other colleges using it and I was so, so eager to have access myself. At the time, there wasnāt actually much to see: tagged photos didnāt even exist yet. But just being able to look at profiles and post on each otherās walls felt thrilling.
Facebookās early days have been on my mind a lot lately, as the A.I. debate has roared in the past couple of months, and the people with trillions of dollars at stake try harder and harder to get us all to love it. I donāt use any of it and I have no use for it; I hate it all. I hate ChatGPTās smarmy voice; I hate the piss filter and āsurprise linesā you see in A.I. art; I hate how A.I. food and A.I. flyers look. I hate that so many of the problems A.I. promises to someday fix could be solved tomorrow if the US simply had a functioning social safety net.
Mostly, I hate the way itās being pushed on us in ways that are either very difficult or impossible to opt out of. I donāt want an A.I. summary ofā¦anything actually, and certainly not of a 2 minute Instagram Reel! I donāt love the idea of it summarizing an email or text I wrote to you. I donāt want A.I. search results and I definitely donāt want A.I. to write my Google doc for me. (As I was writing this blog post, a new feature appeared in Docs offering to āmatch writing style.ā Go away!!!!) I donāt want A.I. memes, or photo edits, or an āagentā to shop for me; I just want to look for an embroidery pattern on Etsy and Pinterest without having to question the fabric of reality. I hate that if I accidentally click the wrong button in an app or on a website, suddenly it starts āthinking,ā furiously cooking up something that I definitely didnāt mean to order. I hate that basically everything Iāve ever written has been used to train it (Iām currently a plaintiff in the class-action suit against Anthropic) and that this blog post will be used to train it too.
In this context, Iāve been thinking a lot about consent, and about the deeply weird men who are pushing all of these products on us. Mark Zuckerberg started Facebook (initially called Facemash) as a Harvard-specific version of āhot or not,ā using photos of girls he took from sorority house websites. That was the plan: He didnāt set out to undermine democracy around the worldā¦merely to undermine how young women felt about themselves. Male entitlement is in the social webās DNA.
Two decades and multiple lawsuits later, we know definitively that Facebook and Instagram and the rest are bad for young womenās mental health. Meta is all grown up. So, what is it offering the world at this moment? Well, thereās the utterly pointless $400 glasses that have made it necessary to wonder if some pervert is covertly recording us as we go about our everyday lives, and thereās Muse, an A.I. agent that is giving out your address on Marketplace and compiling dossiers on all of your friends.
Meanwhile, ChatGPT thinks you should kill yourself.
Oh, and the entire economy is riding on the success of all of this shit. I discovered a few weeks ago that my retirement is heavily invested in NVIDIA, which means itās extremely dependent on one guy not cheating on his wife.
Very very very cool!
The good news is that the tide really appears to be turning as of late. The midterms sent a resounding āWe fucking hate your vibeā to Silicon Valley, to the media outlets that have been credulously slurping up CEOsā hype for the past few years, and, I hope, to Chuck Schumer, who confidently told the team at OpenA.I., āYouāre doing important work. We donāt fully understand it, but itās important.ā
If you want to learn more about A.I., the absolutely rancid culture that is financing it and building it, and exactly whatās at stake right now, here are some recommendations (with as many gift links as possible!).
PBSās Ghost in the Machine documentary (free on YouTube)
Empire of A.I.: Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenA.I.
Blood in the Machine: The Origins of the Rebellion Against Big Tech
The Nerd Reich: Silicon Valley Fascism and the War on Democracy
Deep Unlearning (this one isnāt out yet, but I have a galley and itās very good/harrowing!)
Inside the U.S. āKill Chainā that Destroyed an Iranian School
A.I. Is Changing Everything About Hacking. No One Knows What Happens Next
She Trusted ChatGPT With Her Medication Decisions. It Cost Her Everything.
Cops left the force. They kept tracking people with a powerful camera network.
ChatGPT Helped Tumbler Ridge Shooter Focus on Guns, Tactics, and Terror
Google Pushed A.I. Into Schoolsāand Even Students Say Itās Gone Too Far
Middle-Schoolers Are Seeking Out A.I. Friends Instead of Real Human Ones
Battle of Hospital A.I. vs. Insurer A.I. Is Pushing Medical Costs Higher
A.I. is already deciding whether or not people receive medical care
New Amazon Data Center Stokes Worry It Would Be the Most Polluting Power Plant in the U.S.
āPure arroganceā: anger in Finland as Google illegally fells 250,000 trees for datacentre
Itās time to block reckless A.I. IPOs and tax billionaires
āThere Is One Fightā: American Voters Reject Tech Oligarchy
Changing our relationship to technology will require collective action
The other piece of all of this is that I have never wanted to be on my phone less. The internet sucks now! Iām having all of my shit scraped and Iām not having fun! My life lately has also been influenced by Against Convenience: Embracing Friction in an Age of Endless Ease. (After reading it, I commissioned a Vox article by Gabe Bullard about how to decide whether or not to incorporate new technology into your life.)
Iāve never been a huge poster and had already cut way back on Instagram and stopped using TikTok, but Iāve been making even more of an effort to be off of my phone and in the world more. I recently enabled Downtime and set screen time limits. Itās not great timingāI really should be out there promoting my book right nowābut I just find all of it nauseating and also so boring.
So, what to do instead? I was really inspired by an article my colleague Sara Herschander wrote about how we lost our sense of touch. Since reading it, and after later speaking to one of the experts for my Vox deep dive on junk journaling, Iāve been making a very concerted effort to have really tactile experiences every single day, and ideally creative ones. Iāve hand-quilted four quilts this year, and I really enjoy doing it. I love feeling the weight of the quilt draped over me and the friction of the thread as I pull it through the fabric. I finished my most recent one a couple of weeks ago and have felt lightly bereft ever since! Iāve also been getting really into appliquĆ©, and because Etsy is filled to the brim with slop, Iāve been purchasing instructional books that are roughly 30 years old on Thriftbooks because at least then I can be sure that a human created it.
Working on appliquƩ/embroidery on the beach this summer
My finished garlic appliquƩ project
Progress photo of the dog bed Iām making for Valentina
Progress photo of an embroidery project from The Fabled Thread, a birthday gift from my mom
The double Irish chain quilt I finished a couple of weeks ago
One tiny upside of all of this is that itās really made me appreciate human messiness and mistakes more, particularly in creative work. I have become so much more forgiving of my own stuff; the inconsistencies and āerrorsā that once would have bugged me now just read as proof of human involvement. Right now, Iām interested in the things you can reach out and touch, that you can feel with your fingers and hold in your hands.